保罗沃森和沉没“Ady Gil”

那里有很多保护组织,一切都希望为他们的原因筹集资金。它's rare that you see a call to sign a petition etc. that is not automatically asking you for money, after you signed it. There is nothing inherently wrong with asking for money, because there are cost involved with saving the oceans. With some groups however, making money seems to be the main purpose, regardless of who, or what they hurt in the process. Take the following example.

2010年“ady gil.“,一艘由此操作的小船只 海牧羊犬保护协会 与日本捕鲸船相撞"Shonan Maru 2..."以后沉没了一段时间。"SSCS."一直声称造成碰撞损坏"ady gil." is what caused her to sink and maintained that the Japanese intentionally rammed their vessel.

There is video evidence that the collision itself was actually caused by the captain of the "ady gil.",加速进入路径"Shonan Maru 2..."在最后一刻。在这个视频中,你可以看到"ady gil."在水中停下来,碰撞前有一点船只在船上背后有白色的白色迹象表明它从事道具并加速前进,直到日本船的道路。 

This video has led some people to accuse SCCS of intentionally causing this accident to create publicity for their "鲸鱼战争"电视节目并从他们的支持者筹集资金。一世'不指责队长"ady gil."试图故意打破日本船。我认为它's more likely that he wanted to cut right in front of it to get some dramatic TV footage and simply miscalculated, the claim that SSCS created this whole event gained some credibility, when in the aftermath of the sinking, 皮特伯恩, the captain of the "ady gil." came out and stated that he deliberately sank the vessel on the orders of 保罗沃森.

Sea Shepherd maintained that the "ady gil."由于在碰撞期间遭受了损害而沉没,并且他们一切都努力拯救它。 在回复Bethune的录取时,SSCS发布了这一点 陈述 由沃森。部分阅读: “那么为什么Bechune决定向媒体和公众做出这样的指责,我命令他沉沦贴身吉尔?

The answer is obvious. I fired him the day before for providing false statements to the Japanese police. He then threatened to make this allegation against me if I did not reinstate him. I refused. In fact, I sent Bethune’在他发布之前对媒体的威胁。"

听到Bethune后's confession, ady gil.,一个人捐赠100万美元的人和船被命名为后,最终结束了 起诉 他们丢失了船只。经过多年来回,去年9月,仲裁员在这种情况下终于发布了一个 裁决 现在成为公众。

该裁决包括对Paul Watson的严厉评估: "仲裁员找到了沃森先生’关于某些事件的证词,以高度逃避,内部矛盾,或与他自己的事先书面陈述的赔率,在某些地区,只是缺乏真正激励信心和信任的真正认真的基本标记"

所以现在我们知道 保罗沃森 ordered the deliberate sinking of the "ady gil."

几天以前, 夹克迅速, former captain of the Sea Shepherd vessel "鲍勃巴克"也出来并公开承认"ady gil."故意沉没并在Facebook上发出公众道歉,因为他的角色。 

是的。我和Pete Bethune和Luke Vanhorn一起携带了船只Ady Gil并故意被嘲笑它。我们沉没了船只Ady Gil并撒谎,在SSC的内外和外面撒谎,以掩盖真相。 你可以阅读他的整个陈述 这里

Why was it so important to Paul Watson to sink the "ady gil."? 在加入沃森先生的要求之前, (故意骂船) Mr. Swift recalls that he asked Mr. Watson, “为什么这对你这么重要?”和沃森先生回应,“我们的观众需要关闭。” 我想这说明了   where Paul Watson'优先事项是。娱乐观众比他声称关心的更重要。当然,Watson没有关于这个事实的努力"关闭"他向他的电视观众提供了一个公然的谎言,他没有'犹豫使用谎言筹集资金。  

从裁决: Of course, whatever the rationale for deceiving the viewing public (which might be presumed to understand that “reality shows”实际上没有反映现实) 

Here are some excerpts from the arbitrators ruling, that offer insight into the reasons the SSCS wanted to scuttle the "ady gil."如何"真实的" "鲸鱼战争" really is.

这些证据表明,尽管有些损害与日本舰队的碰撞发生了损害,但Ady Gil不太可能下沉。  

船员’s thinking
(向Ady Gil Scuttle) 似乎直接受到动物行星剧组机组人员的存在的影响,这使得SSCs无与伦比的公众曝光,大大扩大了其筹资可能性。  
当然,将拖曳操作置于岸上的牵引操作不会为有趣的电视观察而制造 

相比之下,湘南玛鲁#2与Ady Gil的碰撞已经捕获了无与伦比的媒体关注,Watson先生向史蒂夫·伊尔文和Pete Bethune采访了鲍勃巴克的不间断媒体呼吁采访。船员是 敏锐意识到Ady Gil的沉没会为更加戏剧性的现实电视创造场合  


Indeed, Mr. Swift testifies that “在我们的讨论/争论期间,导致我对保罗的投资’坐下来沉沦阿迪吉尔,他告诉我......‘哦,媒体对此会很棒。’” 



Paul’s a genius, and he’特别是媒体天才。有时他’他的开放性,有时候,他’没有。而且,当他对他的思想造成他的思想’像一个斗牛斗牛队获得锁下颌,我无法改变主意,这就是为什么我最终执行他的订单 


As for the scene in "鲸鱼战争", where Bethune and Swift discussed abandoning the ship: 对相机的决定阶段这一现场是Bechune先生和Swift先生在动物星球人员面前讨论的结果: 他们说我们需要创造一个让它看起来像是决定放弃船的场景。我从Whale War的角度看,......决定被船长放弃船是一个非常强大的场景。我和它一起去了
仲裁员提供了这个想法。 当然,无论欺骗观察公众的理由吗(可能被推测到解“​​现实表明”实际上反映现实),欺骗申请人没有法律或道德理由,欺骗申请人,Ady Gil的所有者。

So we know that SSCS and Paul Watson have no problem deceiving their supporters and the viewers of "鲸鱼战争" who think that the series is an actual documentary. What is interesting to find out is that they equally have no problem with throwing their own employees, donors and volunteers under the bus, blaming them for their own actions.

There are many great organizations working to save the oceans and it'居民,我鼓励支持他们。在选择您想要支持的之前,请仔细检查它们。 

干杯,
马丁格拉夫
首席执行官鲨鱼潜水员 


关于鲨鱼潜水员。作为商业鲨鱼潜水和保护倡议的全球领导者鲨鱼潜水员已经花了过去十年,为世界各地的鲨鱼订婚。我们的博客突出了这些动态和移位世界的所有方面。您可以直接在员工@sharkdiver.com直接联系我们。